Calgary city council has repealed a bylaw that mandated businesses to impose a minimum bag fee and only offer single-use items upon customer request. 

The controversial bylaw, which only went in force on January 16, was scrapped after a brief public hearing on Tuesday.

The bylaw initially required businesses to charge 15 cents for paper bags and one dollar for reusable bags. Additionally, it stipulated that food establishments should only provide napkins, cutlery, and condiments when requested by customers. 

“I think the message has been sent out really clearly that we’re scrapping this and we’re starting again,” said Ward 3 Councillor Jasmine Mian, who spearheaded the motion to repeal the bylaw. 

City administration noted that after the bylaw’s implementation, one fast-food outlet reported a 10-20% decrease in customers opting for paper bags at the drive-thru, showcasing some level of effectiveness in reducing single-use waste.

Despite the repeal, some council members expressed concerns about the need for ongoing discussions on waste reduction. 

Ward 11 Councillor Kourtney Penner, who opposed the repeal, lamented over the need for behavioural change in Calgary.

Smith opposed bylaw

On January 27th, Premier Smith sought public opinion through a social media poll, asking, “Do you support the ‘single-use items bylaw’ in Calgary and Edmonton that forces consumers to use paper straws and request napkins with their meals?” 

The response was overwhelming, with over 36,000 participants and 87.2% voting against the bylaw.

Calgary Councillor Andre Chabot said he received dozens of emails after the bylaw came into effect.

“Mostly I’ve heard from folks saying they think it’s ridiculous that they have to ask for a napkin or that they have to ask for a spoon, or that they have to ask for a straw,” he said.