Judge rules Deena Hinshaw isn’t protected by ‘cabinet confidentiality’

TCS Wire

April 27, 2022

In the constitutional challenge against the government over pandemic-related restrictions, a judge has ruled that Alberta’s Chief Medical Officer Deena Hinshaw must release her conversations with government officials.

“The public interest in disclosing Dr. Hinshaw’s answers to the questions posed by the court outweighs the public interest in keeping the evidence confidential,” Justice Barbara Romaine stated.

Hinshaw and her lawyers cited ‘cabinet confidentiality’ to avoid revealing the closed-door discussions she had with politicians regarding the restrictive mandates put in place by the province.

The judge continued, “I find that, whether or not the evidence falls within the scope of public interest immunity, it is admissible as both relevant and necessary to fairly dispose of this case and to assist the Court in determining the facts upon which the decision in the case will depend.”

Furthermore, the judge said that hiding behind confidentiality would be “to use this form of privilege to shield the Alberta government from allegations of political interference with respect to decisions made under the Public Health Act.”

Hinshaw’s trial is part of an over-one-year-old case launched by Albertans against the government over pandemic-related restrictions they want to have ruled unconstitutional. Until recently, Hinshaw managed to dodge her day in court, claiming to be too busy handling the pandemic to possibly make an appearance, despite going on vacation last year the same week as when she was scheduled to appear.

Lawyers Leighton Grey, on behalf of the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, and Jeff Rath are representing the plaintiffs.

Hinshaw has previously admitted in court that it was necessary to shut down businesses and places of worship for a virus that wasn’t a threat to 96 per cent of the population for the greater good.

As Sheila Gunn Reid from Rebel News reported from the courtroom, Hinshaw ultimately fell back on hospital capacity as the reason for the restrictions on everyone:

“GREY: your orders impacted the liberties of 96 per cent of Albertans who were at no risk of serious health outcomes or death.”

“HINSHAW: if the hospitals are overwhelmed, healthy people could be impacted by a knock-on effect if they are not able to access the healthcare system.”

Hinshaw’s defence is appealing the judge’s decision, hoping they never have to reveal what was said between Hinshaw and government leaders.

Share this story

Help Keep your News Free

Share this story

It's crucial we stay in touch

Big Tech wants to censor us, that’s why you need to stay in touch.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE THESE...

Trending News

The Ontario Physicians and Surgeons Discipline tribunal (OPSDT) is currently investigating whether professional misconduct occurred by three doctors who did not follow its recommendations for Covid-19 treatment. 

Dan Fournier

December 6, 2022

Trending News

Montreal Canadiens goaltender Carey Price has ignited a viral social media trend after publicly disavowing the Trudeau Liberals’ proposed amendment to gun-ban bill C-21.

Mike Campbell

December 5, 2022

Trending News

An NDP-led protest against Alberta Premier Danielle Smith’s proposed Sovereignty Act legislation was a major flop, with only a handful of attendees showing up. 

Keean Bexte

December 5, 2022

Trending News

Republican senators threatened to delay funding towards National Defense until the “insane” vaccine mandate for US military members is removed. 

Mike Campbell

December 1, 2022

Trending News

A Calgary judge just let an indigenous man avoid a federal prison sentence despite having slit a stranger’s throat on the subway in May. 

Keean Bexte

November 30, 2022

Trending News

Western University finally dropped its COVID 19 vaccine mandate on Tuesday, after months of petitions and protests against the institution.

TCS Wire

November 29, 2022

We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners who may combine it with other information that you’ve provided to them or that they’ve collected from your use of their services. You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.